OPINION: Black culture is not yours to take
Trendiness is not only means of validation for Black culture
May 5, 2020
Cultural appropriation and stealing from Black culture isn’t a new phenomenon.
From Kylie Jenner and Kim Kardashian-West to Fergie in the 2000s, white women and celebrities love to take Black culture and use it to their benefit — but they don’t love the Black people who created their styles.
Story continues below tweet.
Culture appropriation has been a “thing”, its just being called out more now because black people have a platform to do so . White people have been culture appropriating ever since hip hop culture became a “thing” pic.twitter.com/TEiDZdv5gl
— Naj 💕 (@NajaMcdonald) April 22, 2020
There is a difference between appropriation and appreciation. But Kylie Jenner wearing a durag is not a fashion statement; it’s cultural appropriation.
Durags are linked to the head wraps that women wore during slavery. Today, Black people often have to remove their durags in hopes of succeeding in the corporate world.
White women often appropriate Black culture and use it as an accessory and a personality trait.
Culture isn’t a personality trait.
Black women can’t remove their melanin like white women can remove their tan and only apply it when they want to.
White women like the Kardashians and Jenners take pieces that they like from other cultures and adopt them as their own.
Box braids, cornrows, durags, long acrylic nails and weaves stem from Black culture.
What is the difference between a white woman and a Black woman wearing long acrylic nails? Nothing, except that Black women are called “unprofessional” and “tacky” for wearing them while white women are seen as trendsetters.
Do people even know where braided protective hairstyles, like cornrows, stem from?
During slavery, women would braid maps and signals into their hair so the other slaves on the plantation could find out directions without getting caught by the slave owners. Today, people in society often see cornrows as urban, but they have a deeper historical significance.
When white women wear cornrows they are called edgy and innovative, but Black women are seen as angry and unapproachable.
Black women used to be called bald headed and had their wigs snatched from their heads, but now many celebrities wear wigs and are praised for making them a part of mainstream culture.
RELATED: Sac State students embrace their culture through hair
It doesn’t go the other way. Straight hair is genetic — it isn’t a hairstyle like box braids and cornrows that have a historical tie to a specific culture.
When Black women wear their hair straight they are not appropriating “white culture.” They are participating in cultural assimilation to have a chance at being accepted in a society run predominantly by whites.
It is more than fashion and mannerisms that are appropriated, it’s also our slang.
I’ll never understand why white people want to adopt the terms used by the Black community when they tell those same people that they “talk Black.”
Once co-opted by mainstream culture, the influence of these “trends” is removed from the culture itself and credited to celebrities.
If you feel the need to steal fashion and styles from Black culture, at the bare minimum you need to credit the Black women you are stealing from.
RELATED: SHIAVON’S JAWN: I am not a person of color — I’m Black
The same level of accountability needs to be held when other minority communities steal and appropriate Black culture.
When non-Black minority groups take from Black culture they are still participating in cultural appropriation, it doesn’t change because both groups are minorities.
Culture is historical and the severity of the action doesn’t change based on who is participating in the appropriation. If it isn’t a part of your culture then there is not a reason for you to use it.
Tiarnne • Oct 12, 2020 at 12:14 am
Saying braids are for one type of human is like saying only females can wear a dress and makeup. Times have changed. The African history is horrible, but the past is the past, and we should all be working together to create a future of unity amongst all races. And at the end of the day, if something makes you happy, then you do you and ignore everyone else. Happiness should never be dependent on outside influences.
Danii • Oct 7, 2020 at 9:18 pm
This entire topic is stupid. It’s all-out divisiveness. Knock it off. It’s ridiculously shallow. Whatever happened to “Imitation is the highest form of flattery”?
Iza Johannu • Sep 30, 2020 at 10:28 pm
I’m a white woman, here to try to understand and to be respectful of other’s culture, paying tribute and ensure my young girls are not offensive to others cultures.
I found that there is so much hate here, in the article and in the responses. It’s sad. I feel I can’t just be a respectful loving caring person without walking on eggshells to not offend. It’s too much anger and i forgiveness, like no matter what I do it wouldn’t be enough. So sad that things are so divided. I really do just love people of all kinds.
Anonymous • Sep 30, 2020 at 4:12 pm
I’m curious to know…
I’m originally from South Africa, as so is my generations of family going back to the early 1800s,
As a child I had braids regularly, I’m not black, I’m white, I have extremely naturally curly hair, ( yes it does go into an Afro)
Why is it not ok for me to get braids, truth being people in Africa don’t make things like this about cultural appropriation? I was brought up in a African culture, I’m really confused about this.
✨A✨ • Sep 25, 2020 at 11:42 pm
Hey @anna If you don’t want to appropriate my culture just don’t add weave/fake hair to it You can do the style tho
✨A✨ • Sep 25, 2020 at 11:39 pm
To all the dumb ppl out here white ppl have no culture black people can be born with straight hair black women are the only women that can giver birth to any race with any hair type or eye color you need to learn that when you get box braids it’s highly offensive their are over 1000 hairstyles why steal the only hairstyle in our culture that has so much meaning behind it don’t get box braids or cornrows if you aren’t black simple as that
Merissa Murphy • Sep 18, 2020 at 6:01 pm
I am 12 and was wondering if I could get box braids
im white not hate to all the beautiful balck queens and kings
anna • Sep 15, 2020 at 10:16 am
i have one question. what if i know history behinde braids like where they came from, what they represent. whould it still be cultular approproation if i wear them? what if i just want to respect the culture. is there any way that white women can wear braids without appropriate culture?
Sy • Sep 15, 2020 at 8:12 am
Terry Hogan, blond hair is not a culture, neither is straight hair. cornrows, box braids, and other similar styles were created by the African-American culture, while straight hair is a trait anyone can have, but its more common in caucasians.
Penelope • Sep 4, 2020 at 10:35 pm
My (WHITE) friend has called my “idiotic” because I was trying to tell her simply that there are braids.edges and clothing styles that are black. Hse bought up the fact the when black people straight there hair is cultural appropriation. I just need answers so I can tell her what it is.
Nadyah Coleman • Sep 2, 2020 at 9:38 pm
Hello everyone! I’m a young black girl and I would like to say thank you for everyone’s comments, Now at 14 years old am now just learning about my history and I’m very overwhelmed because I don’t know where to start. I don’t want to be rude to people culture opinions and I really don’t know if I’m being rude for wanting to wear a hanfu( a traditional Chinese dress)… I don’t know how I’m supposed to understand what’s right and what’s not. If anyone can help me out finding my history and show respect to the Chinese history I will be very happy… I wanna learn more about both of them.
Lisa Dorn • Aug 31, 2020 at 4:54 am
??????? Then by all means please explain the dark skin eyes and straight hair of the indigenous peoples of North South Central America ….seriously people….stop it. Or the straight hair but darkskin of the people of India….or the lighter skin but dark straight hair of the people of Asia….or …or …or …or…. or… or… or….everything is NOT cultural appopriation. Otherwise somebody better say SOMETHING to a whole lotta people out there wearing crosses….and NOT acting ANYTHING like Jesus Christ. Some things are appropriation of culture such as specific religious or heritage or lack of known heritage issues and symbols….but most of these things are cosmetic and while there may be a case here and there of a school or employer looking for some outrageous compliance from a student or employee, black women have been wearing their hair loud and proud for 50+ years, so cut the crap already…its causing people unnecessary pain, it’s hypocritical and a bold faced lie.
Me • Aug 27, 2020 at 1:22 pm
Why can’t people just live in thier skin and be happy with that. I coundn’t care less about others thoughts, history, appropriation or fashion. We are all born unique…
Brian Anderson • Aug 26, 2020 at 9:34 pm
My white 12 year old daughter wants Box braids is it bad for her to have them?
teresa • Aug 19, 2020 at 9:52 am
please read the whole thing before responding:
Hi! Just as a question- if a non-black man -for example- wears a durag but gives credit to black people, and also defends black lives and respects them, would he be able to wear it without it being considered cultural appropriation?
The thing is I’m kind of confused about it. Of course we must give the credit to the people that invented it, and I understand the consequences that the years of systematic oppression created, but, wouldn’t it be better to openly show black culture and educate other people about rather than just forbidding it? For example, talking about this in schools and teaching people about it so they know the roots of it and are educated about it, so then they can wear it and appreciate the beautiful black culture.
I don’t mean to be disrespectful and i’m sorry if i’m perceived as one or if someone gets offended, I just wanted to be educated about this subject and given answers. Thank you!:)
Sara Brittin • Aug 14, 2020 at 10:56 pm
(I’m BLACK) All of those ignorant comments gave me a headache do you know how uneducated some of you guys are. The first human beings were covered in hair they were able to get rid of the hair because of the African Sun. When their hair came off they had a copper skin tone. Generations a generation their skin naturally got darker so they could be protected from the cancerous sun. They had Curly kinky hair to protect their scalp from the sun. Generations after they were able to learn how to make fire and hunt. With the fire they were able to cook their food and cooking food would give you lots more energy than raw meat. They felt prepared to explore other parts of the world. The first wave of Humans( mind you now dark-skinned humans) were a not really prepared some groups died off and most returned. A few generations after they were able to move out of Africa again this time being able to survive. They moved throughout the Continents until what is today. For the majority of the European Existence, they were dark-skinned black. Ok? For more than 44,000 years they were dark-skinned the first human to ever have blue eyes were dark-skinned black. Why that is is because they didn’t need brown eyes to protect them from the sun. They were mutating. Soon their skin started getting whiter and their hair started getting straighter. Their hair also started getting blonde becuse they didn’t need to protect their hair. They didn’t need black skin to protect them from the sun because they had a cool environment. They didn’t need Curly hair to protect their scalps from the sun. This was less than 9,000 years ago and humans have existed for 200,000 years. In the past generations, Vikings and white-skinned humans would trade with other countries including in Africa. With that, they would also take the culture of Black people. The earliest cultural appropriation. Black people wore braids to grow their hair and to label them. Like if you were married you would have a certain style if you were the king you would have a certain style. Its all beautiful and it has a history. Years later white people came kidnapped, rapped, and tried to wipe them off their culture. They shaved off our hair because they wanted to make us look unhuman as possible even though we’re more humans than them. During slavery, black people would braid their hair like maps or store food in their hair when escaping from slavery. It was a life or death situation. After the north won the war black woman wanted to express their beauty with their beautiful hair so they started expressing their African heritage wearing braids. White females were getting jealous and soon they passed a law that is you have textured African like hair cover it up. So Black women did to be accepted in society but wearing scarves tied in a Beautiful way. That only made them look even more beautiful so a woman named CJ Walker started making hair products and relaxers so the Black woman could be accepted. Several Black inventors soon made the flat iron and hot comb. Black women are not culturally appropriating they are just trying to fit in with predominantly white society. Most Of the world today I run under the influence of European Beauty standard so much that little girls with beautiful melanated skin and harming their skin and hair to be accepted in an oppressor world. White People have nothing to claim and its gross u guys think that you are the high ones when naturally your not. White people and non-black people are the recessive traits Black people are dominant. You wouldn’t be here if black people were here respect that. And you can’t relate your traits that came from black people with the modern traits black people got appressed for having. Your History isn’t that seasoned.
lyric • Aug 13, 2020 at 5:11 pm
Mark what exactly do you mean by “caucasian hair”
lyric • Aug 13, 2020 at 11:25 am
CassieR if i were you I really like them and enjoy them but i dont want to wear them in public
lyric • Aug 13, 2020 at 11:13 am
First of all,if your hair is naturally curly and goes into an afro than no it is not cultural appropriating,I mean its the way you were born,you cant help it.BUT if you were to do something to it to make it be that way then yeah it would be ca.
LAURA E • Aug 3, 2020 at 12:40 pm
I have been taking paid classes from Mizani for hair knowledge for textured hair. All textures of hair, but primarily curly and coily textures. As a hairdresser, it is deeply important to me to level the playing field and create an inclusive world. However, I have such a conundrum about what is culturally appropriate?
I appreciate what the writer of article and the following comments have to say, and my takeaway is to be respectful in hair design. I will always ask questions, and approach my work in an open way, so as to be inclusive and educated in my process. I learned from this article and others, to give credit to origin, and to work with appreciation of of cultural heritage. one think for sure in hairstyling is, there are no new ideas. if you can reach back far enough, there is an example to learn from. But the gift of hairdressing is that it’s a creative form of expression. Hairstyle is as uniquely personal as a fingerprint. No two people have the exact same head of hair.
But it’s the people of today, that we must be cognisant of. A hairstyle makes an overt statement that should be acknowledged and respected. Our choices of hairstyle may differ, but we all deserve the same respect. And the same attention to care of execution to enhance what we each like about ourselves. This is my path, to learn what is special about each head of hair I style, to be creative, and to respect the process.
Sydney Papageorgiou • Aug 2, 2020 at 2:56 pm
My Greek grandmother wore a braided crown until the day she died. She had long gray/black hair that she braided everyday. It was a part of her culture. She also wore a gold ankle bracelet and nose ring. Once again, it was her culture; she didn’t take any of it from any other culture.
CassieR • Jun 27, 2020 at 2:01 pm
So what does it mean if my black friend braided my hair in box braids? I’m a white girl and she seemed to have no problem doing this to my hair. Would it make it wrong if were to wear them in public or wrong to take them because she spent a lot of time and entertain doing them. I didn’t ask for her to do them but when she offered I didn’t say no.
Dédé • May 27, 2020 at 9:52 am
And why do Black people defend so much what is our culture (I’m black). It’s because for years black people were forbidden to have their cultural hairstyle. Black people created a lot of things but never got the credit.
What is still ours now we cherish and protect it because when White people started getting interested in something from Black people that always stole it.
Music for exemple. Most of what you know today was made by black people the only music created by White was classical music and opera. The rest was made by blacks but stolen by White’s who just took the songs and put their name on it.
Why are Kardashian’s braids making so much noise?
It’s because first she wore braids who come from Africa (that’s cool, really cool) but she gave the credit to bo Derek. While black people wore that hairstyle for centuries, used it as a symbol in society, as a way to know where you are from, as a way to fight against oppression, as a way to empower themselves, to feel pretty or to get closer to their culture it just needs one white person to wear it to erase all the history of this hairstyle, to be called a trendsetter, make money with it and people even give you the credit of it.
I can give you the example of twerk being attributed to Miley Cyrus, Rock n Roll to Elvis Presley, Rap to Eminem, Whiskey to Jack Daniel’s family and Even America to white people who just killed 95% of the Native American population and took million of African to build the economy we know today.
The discovery of America has even been stolen since Christopher Colombus ask a west African King the way to the new world. The proof is that another European explorer found a black village when he arrived on an island in the carribean and that Art has been found showing Dark skinned with Native American fighting against European Colonizer.
I can give you the example of the black girls who allied America to go on the moon but never received credit until recently.
She is not an angry black woman. She is a black women who doesn’t want to see her (future) kids believe that Black people didn’t invent anything or were I civilized and uneducated like her ancestors saw their kids believe.
She is a black woman who doesn’t want to see Future generations believe that Black people did nothing especially since she knows that culturally when brought a lot to this world.
Sorry I assumed that you were a black women if it is wrong I am sorry
And just so you know it’s not just White people who do cultural appropriation. You can come from everywhere and be accused of cultural appropriation.
Last thing: Braids aren’t just a black thing but cornrows are part of black culture. That’s what Kardashian was wearing it was not a European braid ( it can be French, Dutch, Norwegian, Spanish, etc) but and African braid that has deep history and meaning in both African and African American culture.
Dédé • May 27, 2020 at 9:21 am
-Blonde hair isn’t just on White people. There are tribes in Africa (I think Ethiopia) that have people with blond or even red hair.
-europeans had contacts with Africa since even before Antiquity. Greeks had contacts with North Africa and North Africa had strong contacts with Sudanese people since they were usually at war. There was even black pharaon (The Kush)
Persian and Arabs also had contacts with
Black African since they were the links in trades between Europe, Africa and Asia.
Swahili ( a language spoken in West Africa) exists because of those trade links.
-Wigs were and are worn by White wealthy families in Europe and America but it was taken by black people to be able to be intergrated in the American society since Black Natural Hair weren’t really accepted.
And also since Black hair are hard to grow without protection hairstyle (like dreadlocks, and braids) They used wigs to make it easier to have long hair and style it as they want
Killer Marmot • May 21, 2020 at 7:24 pm
Blacks, whites, and other races and cultures have borrowed ideas from each other since time began, to everyone’s ultimate benefit. It’s absurd to tell one culture they can’t borrow from another. There is no rationale to it.
Terry Hogan • May 21, 2020 at 6:28 pm
I understand about taking from one culture and using it as your own., how it would not be right, even though you could.
I was just curious as a Scottish, Irish woman, isn’t the use of all the wigs of different colors and styles and wearing them as if they were your culture as wrong? What would be the benefit of black women wearing blond wigs and weaves and red wigs and weaves not taking Caucasian culture too? So my question is why is it ok for black women to wear hair to look like Caucasian hair , but wrong if Caucasian women wear say an Afro? I mean no disrespect, but truly curious. Thank you so much for your answer!
Sithelo • May 6, 2020 at 10:21 am
Facts, keep on preaching sister