OPINION: Taylor Swift will always be polarizing no matter what
February 16, 2020
I love Taylor Swift. A lot. And I am not afraid to say it.
I have been a fan since 2006. I remember hearing “Tim McGraw” play on Radio Disney when I was 8 years old and I was hooked.
Just to establish my authority: I have seen her in concert nine times (three of which were on the “reputation” Stadium tour), met her in Arlington, Texas on Oct. 5, 2018 after her concert and have a tattoo of her lyrics.
I might sound crazy but we all have our passions. Mine is just Taylor Swift.
However, I am not one of those fans who blindly supports everything she does just because she is doing it. At the core, my belief system is calling out things I do not agree with.
For years, Taylor has been called a snake and people have always said she plays the victim, especially in relation to the Kanye West and Kim Kardashian phone call fiasco of 2016.
Hate tweets about her were a common thing for years. They slowed down during the “reputation” era and the beginning of the “Lover” era (her newest album) and for the most part, social media was quiet about her. Until this month.
On Jan. 31, her documentary “Miss Americana” hit Netflix after premiering at the Sundance Film Festival on Jan. 23. The film showcased her personal life as a megastar and how her thinking processes have changed over the years.
To be honest, I was nervous. It was being sold as Taylor finding her political voice and not being afraid to stand up for what she believes in. I was scared to see how the public would take that.
Obviously, I was excited to get another movie about her but I was still nervous. I do not handle people being unnecessarily mean to Taylor very well. It hurts my feelings.
One scene in particular made me hesitant. I knew people would have issues with it because she is Taylor Swift.
Even if she is doing something good, people find some reason to hate it.
The scene was about how she wanted to speak out and finally make a political statement, yet her team did not want her to. She spoke about the fear instilled in her ever since she was a new artist that she would end up like the Dixie Chicks or that people did not care about what she had to say.
Taylor’s whole shtick has always been how she’s being perceived. It has nothing to do with standing up for marginalized folks. When it was profitable to be racist, she was. Now it’s profitable for her to be progressive, so she is. No spine on this 🐍 https://t.co/tG4MhHcgeQ
— Hating Lizzo is Not a Personality Trait (@biguyreviews) February 1, 2020
I doubt this person watched the documentary and saw how emotional she was talking about everything. The main plot point is that she cared too much about how she was perceived in the public but that now she does not.
She also talked about her regrets for not saying anything sooner and expressed that she wished she had before. But apparently that is not enough. It was a lose-lose situation.
It is still funny to me that people thought she was a secret Republican even though she dated Conor Kennedy, grandson of Robert F. Kennedy, in 2012 and has a friendship with Ethel Kennedy.
If speaking out about Marsha Blackburn, the Republican running for Senator in Tennessee, made Taylor’s father Scott Swift upset, he would not be too happy about his daughter being close with one of the most famous Democratic families in American history.
She had more to lose from this than to gain yet people still said she was doing it for selfish reasons.
That scene was tiny and even though people are upset, I am glad she included it.
“I think that it is so frilly and spineless of me to stand on stage and go ‘happy pride month you guys’ and then not say this when someone is literally coming for their neck,” Taylor said in the documentary when preparing to post on Instagram about the midterm elections in 2018.
That quote made me proud to be a fan. It was reassurance of what I already knew about her, that it was not just for show.
Whether you want to accept it or not, her words and actions have impact and meaning.
Within 24 hours of her post, over 65,000 people registered to vote on vote.com and her Equality Act Petition has received over half a million signatures.
Her fighting for LGBTQ+ rights meant so much to her fans that it drowns out all the backlash she received for it.
Society will never agree on if they like Taylor Swift or not but you can not discredit all the things she has done.
Also, stop telling me that you do not like Taylor or her music. Congrats. I do not care.
Emily • Feb 19, 2020 at 12:20 am
I am not a fan of Taylor as a person, I like some of her music; I generally try to ignore celebrity politics so I don’t know too much about her personal life. But, I’m glad to hear that she has broken free from the men in her life who were silencing her, especially her dad, I can relate to that. And although it is very plausible imo that some of her suddenly activist proclamations are for good publicity and $$, it is always good to have another big voice in the fray speaking out in favor of making the world a better place for everyone. Some people really do hold opinions and vote based on what their personal idols say and believe, and the more important people publicly express progressive views, the better.
Sally Dingley • Feb 18, 2020 at 11:43 am
Taylor Swift is a strong amazing woman. I love her music.
Jenniifer M. • Feb 17, 2020 at 7:55 pm
This article reflects completely my feelings. Happy to be a Taylor fan.
Pamela Timmins • Feb 17, 2020 at 4:25 pm
I love Taylor, I love her music. She is my favorite singer and musian of all time and the best entertainer ever! I have been a fan since I saw her sing “Tim McGraw” to Tim McGraw and Faith Hill, since 2006. I watched her Reputation tour on Netflix and Miss Americana several times on Netflix I loved both. I have all her cd’s and videos. I saw her in the CATS MOVIE her performance was excellent and worth seeing the movie.
Robert J • Feb 17, 2020 at 9:42 am
Nice post! I agree that people or either going to choose to dismiss or hate Taylor no matter what she says or does, and usually that is alright. However, I do think that if they are going to spew nonsense, it’s probably better to just stay quiet. I’m a Taylor fan and have been since ‘Tears On My Guitar’. So keep loving her and I’ll be right by your side.
BMK • Feb 17, 2020 at 8:11 am
Great essay, well said.
Sash • Feb 17, 2020 at 8:10 am
I’m also convinced that the author of the hate tweet you included did NOT actually watch the documentary. Too many people get what they can from brief statements/sound bites of others and its all they need to know to form … and export … an opinion. That whole scene to which you refer was only part of a thread, a process that consumed 1/4 or 1/3 of the film. If that tweet writer HAD watched it, they’d have understood what was really going on. People DO grow and evolve, and we were just seeing part of Taylor’s ongoing process.
Donna Brewington • Feb 17, 2020 at 6:48 am
Totally agree with you. I am proud of her for using her platform to speak out. I especially loved when she stayed Senator Blackburn does not represent Christian Tennessee values.
SJ • Feb 17, 2020 at 2:16 am
I’m a superfan like you- I’ve seen her 8 times, 3 in Rep Tour. I’m in college too and really liked everything you said. I agree, that some people just won’t like her no matter what she does. But her impact has been undeniable. Could she be doing more? Sure. But we all could always be doing more. And attacking her instead of the source of the harm is senseless and also harmful. Also those last three sentences were fire. -SJ