OPINION: The takedown of Hobo Johnson
Sacramento’s most popular rapper can’t really rap
The dude just has no rhythm.
OK, now that we have that out of the way, I have to say that I am not trying to wish Frank Lopes or any of his bandmates ill will. Congrats on the success!
I sure don’t get it though.
Since Hobo Johnson’s rise to semi-stardom in Oak Park, now buoyed by his NPR Tiny Desk Concert music video, which currently boasts four million plus views, I can’t contain my genuine perplexity at the prospect.
Like, this is the big Sacramento artist right now?
My critiques of Hobo Johnson can be categorically summed up into two discrete points — his technical clumsiness, and more importantly, the wheedling attitude behind the rhymes.
When a friend of mine showed me “Dear Labels” a year ago, I anticipated a criticism of a bloated, too often myopic industry that has a habit of overlooking quirky artists such as Hobo Johnson.
Or maybe I didn’t know what I was expecting, but I know that it wasn’t a transparent attempt at begging for sympathy and pleading with corporations for fame and money.
The message is this: “No, listen, I’m just such a nice guy that I deserve to be picked up by a major record label after just two albums (the first of which had such a lukewarm reception that it is hardly mentioned alongside “The Rise of Hobo Johnson”) and by the way I love my mom.”
He actually says “Pay my rent and I’ll sell you my soul.” At least he’s honest.
I’m not sure why he feels the need to beg when, according to “Demarcus Cousins and Ashley,” both him and his mother are pretty sure he’s going to be “a somewhat successful rapper.”
I might have forgiven Hobo Johnson’s inability to find the beat if it weren’t for those slimy, sycophantic lyrics.
But Hobo Johnson doesn’t stop there. While he not only slithers about to garner pity and sympathy from record labels, much of his music suggests that he does the same thing for the attention of women.
His Tiny Desk video, “Peach Scone,” is essentially an extended narrative about Hobo himself attempting to get with a friend of his who is in a relationship, trash talking her boyfriend, and making himself out to be the victim in some twisted parody of friendzone edgelording.
The guy’s got terminal-stage nice guy syndrome. You know it’s bad when you have to describe yourself as a “good kid.”
RELATED: Meet the self-described ‘good kids’ behind Hobo Johnson
And for whatever reason, media outlets have been taking the bait since his rise, describing Hobo Johnson as “self-deprecating” and “bullsh*t free,” despite the obvious self-serving bent to his songwriting.
It should be said that the charm of his ‘authentic’ stumbling over lyrics and ‘down to earth’ awkwardness fade quickly, too.
All too often, Hobo Johnson chooses to cut the backing track completely to allow for an a capella rap.
This is a bad idea for a rapper when the rapper in question lacks an internal metronome — the result is word salad.
Rhyming “Fat Joe” with “cardio” with “doctor though,” Hobo Johnson’s lyrics range from mildly amusing to essentially inane.
Someone please tell me what “Parents just don’t understand / Except for Will Smith, he’s got a great understanding” is supposed to mean. Please.
With so many other talented upstart musicians in Sacramento (I think first of singer-songwriter Jessica Malone, recently named artist of the year by Sacramento News & Review, or the incredibly talented but still quite underground funk-fusion musician Brandy Robinson, or the soon-to-be-defunct post progressive group A Lot Like Birds), I expect a little more out of a local rising star.
I have to give credit where credit is due, though. “I love you like the Kings love to lose” will always be hilarious.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Sacramento State University. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Nina • May 17, 2020 at 6:12 pm
Wow, the audacity in this article. Have you listened to his music? His lyrics go deeper then the surface. None of your points were cohesive, and overall stupid. His music is poetry, and gets stuck in my head all day. 6IX9INE is still popular, but his tracks are not even comparable to Frank’s. And there is one clear difference between this article and his music: Frank can write, you can’t. This article made me lose brain cells.
Ben Dover • Aug 29, 2019 at 5:26 pm
This article is complete trash. The author starts it off with saying he has no rhythm and his lyrics are trash. Which is not true at all. You are essentially just insulting this talented kid for no reason. And in peach scone, he is not fighting with this girls boyfriend, it’s a catchy, relatable song. You say he is feeding off of fame and his good kid label. Maybe the author just can’t wrap there head around the thought that he’s actually just a good kid.
Britton • Aug 22, 2019 at 1:38 pm
It’s real music, multiple artists have done it, and just because he dosent have the exact rhythm your used to dosent mean he has no rhythm at all.
Britton • Aug 22, 2019 at 1:34 pm
The rythm is slam poetry/ rap/ rock. He does it on purpose. His songs have messages behind them, and you have to understand them to get the song more. When he says, “no I’m a really nice guy and I deserve to be picked up by a major record company” or whatever along the lines, he sings about his struggles in his career. When he says “pay my rent and I’ll give you my soul” he sings about how he cant seem to make enough money.
Odette • Jul 31, 2019 at 2:55 am
Honestly, this article just felt like you simply hated the artist. For me, his music comes from a dark emotional state and/or trama hes experienced. After reading this article, I can understand that you didnt even pay attention to the songs. Yes, I can agree that Dear Labels was something youd kinda expect from a song of its title, however Peach Scone? Did you listen to only the first 2 lines and then decided the rest of the songs meaning without listening? “… trash talking her boyfriend…” are you kidding me? He literally tells her when shes complaining about how her boyfriend made her mad, that “he’ll turn around at some point”. Yes hes in love with her, and wants to be with her, but he would never ever destroy the love she has. He supports it and helps make sure shes happy. With other songs? It’s that same emotional depth that you fail to mention. Along with stylistic changes, such as the rhythm or notes or melodies, they’re meant to be there. Hobo Johnson will take the emotions he felt writing the lyrics and translate them into every part of the song. Such as Creve Couer 1, were hes talking about not being able to help and love his friend or girlfriend, he used beat changes and falling out of rhythm with particularly strong emotions. Taking into account 3%, where hes rapping about how everyone is trying to squash his dreams of being a successful rapper (which if you listened to it, youd only take it as the “perpetual nice guy” syndrome you’ve deemed him with) he used similar techniques, and added accents to the song. Your lack of understanding, research, and reporting definitely earns some discreditness on your end bud.
Juliet M Cannon • Jun 13, 2019 at 8:57 am
I heard his song Romeo and Juliet once and was hooked. I really like his music or maybe its just the fear that all new music sucks.
karl • Jun 9, 2019 at 7:01 pm
Wow. Look at all the hobolites writing in. Why not have the guy just write down his story and leave it at that? There’s little to no melody, harmony or rhythm in it…which basically makes it NOT MUSIC. If “uniqueness” and “honesty” are enough for you to dub it as “good art,” perhaps hobo can take a crap on a plate onstage and we can put it in a museum and call it art too.
dane • Jun 8, 2019 at 4:12 pm
It’s manic poetry I believe. It’s not exactly supposed to be proper hip-hop or rap as you’re describing. I don’t like this artist personally, but I appreciate the value and know this article is even less articulate than the music it’s trying to ‘takedown’.
nick • Apr 29, 2019 at 11:23 am
ITS ABOUT THE EMOTION HE PUTS INTO ALL OF HIS POEMS AND SONGS.
Keondra • Apr 10, 2019 at 6:33 am
I didn’t quite understand this article. Once you got to peach scone and said that he’s making himself out to be a nice guy, that couldn’t have been more than wrong.
He likes the girl, but knows he can’t be with her, which why he likes the thought of being with her. He compliments the guy she’s daying, saying hey, I hope you guys are happy and I also don’t want to ruin anything between you two.
Regg • Apr 9, 2019 at 3:03 am
The takedowns of this article are more insightful than this supposed “takedown” could ever hope to be
Dean Estes • Oct 4, 2018 at 4:55 pm
You’re a moron. Nothing in this article is any more cohesive or understandable than the music and message behind said music of which you’re bashing. The comments and questions relative to Hobo Johnson’s work/lyrics alone (that you’ve quoted throughout the article of which you’re rhetorically asking the reader (I guess?)) shows your shanty, half-baked research in full. How can you criticize the kid for something you didn’t even take the time to do a fucking google search on? Honestly. To not understand is one thing, but to blindly and stubbornly refuse to do so is going to be the inevitable downfall of you as a journalist. It’s a shame, as I’ve read your work before, to see you plummet to this level of debauchery. Did he not give you an autograph or something? Because frankly I don’t see why else one would spend the time and effort to erroneously bash someone of which they have no reason or platform to do so.
You’re a moron.
Fizz • Aug 17, 2018 at 10:12 am
It’s understandable where the author is coming from, he certainly does not have a typical musician style, as he mixes a lot of comedy into his act. I Recently had the opportunity to see him live at outside lands, and I wouldn’t have necessarily called it a concert, but perhaps it’s more likened to someone one like Reggie Watts (at an immature stage). A comedy act that incorporates music, and interacts with the audience quite a lot. Also, from a musician stand point, there was not much to grasp in regards to the musical composition, but that’s not what he is about, again he is more focused on the comedic interactive side…not a bad thing really, just a different way of garnering attention, which is what all musicians are looking to do.
Kay • Jul 26, 2018 at 8:03 pm
Well this was awful and a waste of time.
I saw hobo last night and that kid is nothing short of special and amazing.
Leif • Jul 9, 2018 at 8:02 am
The fact that you’re completely baffled by the Will Smith reference and couldn’t even look it up is a blatant indicator that you’re just pandering to the horde of idiots whom Frank’s music is too emotional deep and culturally relevant for them to understand. I have read very few articles as lazy and lacking content as this. I will never get those couple minutes back. Don’t quit your day job, unless writing is your day job….
Eric • Jun 18, 2018 at 7:37 am
“Someone please tell me what “Parents just don’t understand / Except for Will Smith, he’s got a great understanding” is supposed to mean. Please.”
The fact that you had to ask this tells me you have no place being a music critic.
William Major • May 29, 2018 at 4:02 am
Did this modern day “kid rock” claim to be from oak park at first? Or was him attempting to garner rap credibility with that whole “im multiracial…my struggle is rap’s struggle”. Face it…youre no “Lil Dicky”. Youre simply another condescending white rapper who is pandering to the “colored folk” with his art. Get your “all lives matter” t f outta here.
Yandu • May 23, 2018 at 6:07 am
The writer completely missed the point in each of his examples. This is terrible article written by someone completely out of touch with the current landscape. What a joke.
Ryan • May 17, 2018 at 7:21 pm
Yeah man I’m not really sure there’s much depth to this article other than an inherent biased contempt for Frank. I think what you’re not taking into account is that state of mind switches the perspective of everything – and Hobo’s music comes from a place of emotional suffering which while you can dismiss as “terminal nice guy syndrome”, to a lot of people is relatable in a way that a lot of artists can’t touch.
And in regard to his technical skill – his ability to fall out of tempo and be haphazard with the tempo is not an accident – it’s indicative of a thorough understanding of melody and the integration of lyrics, which is kinda essential to any great rapper freestyle or otherwise.
Idk I guess I just don’t understand the unfettered hate, and this article doesn’t provide any clarity.
Andy • May 15, 2018 at 6:01 pm
I kept waiting for the takedown part of this article, thinking it would have more substance, but then found the comment section and realized the author was just bandwagon whining. Look at all the quotation marks and imagine having an insufferable conversation with the author and how many times he probably does the airquotes gesture with his fingers.
Collin Chandler • May 14, 2018 at 10:25 am
“Parents just don’t understand/Except for Will Smith, he’s got a great understanding,” is 1) an homage to Grammy Award winning song, “Parents Just Don’t Understand,” released in 1988 by Will Smith and DJ Jazzy Jeff, and 2) likely an acknowledgment that Will Smith, now a parent himself, is cool enough to indeed understand.
Hope this helps, Vincent.