Woman files lawsuit after 4-year-old daughter falls through Sac State staircase railing
Lihua Tang is seeking damages over $25,000
December 4, 2019
After her daughter fell through a staircase railing in Sacramento State’s Capistrano Hall last year, Lihua Tang filed a lawsuit Nov. 13 against the California State University Board of Trustees regarding a complaint of personal injury due to dangerous public property.
The plaintiffs — Tang, her 4-year-old daughter and her 12-year-old-son — filed a claim for over $25,000 in damages.
Sac State President Robert Nelsen, CSU Chancellor Timothy White and Sac State Associate Vice President of Facilities Management Justin Reginato are all named as defendants in the suit, according to the Sacramento Superior Court website.
The lawsuit notes three causes of action: dangerous condition of public property, negligence and negligent infliction of emotional stress.
At the time of publication Sac State, Tang and her lawyer had not responded to requests for comment.
On Dec. 1, 2018, Tang and her two children were at Capistrano Hall for her son’s music audition. According to the complaint filed by Tang and her children’s attorney Alicia Boytin, Tang was approaching the check-in table in room 142-A and her children were a few feet away.
Then Tang said she heard a thud and a cry.
Story continues below excerpt.
Tang’s daughter fell approximately nine feet from the staircase railing to the floor, the complaint said.
The California State University claim form submitted on April 29 said the daughter suffered injuries including a fractured wrist, fractured teeth, fractured jaw, lacerations and soft tissue injuries.
According to the claim, the medical expenses for her treatment were deemed to be over $60,000.
Tang and her son both claim severe emotional damages on account of the daughter’s injuries.
The lawsuit said that the University failed to comply with Government Code Section 835 and 835.2, which states that “a public entity is liable for injury caused by a dangerous condition of its property if… the property was in a dangerous condition at the time of the injury,” and that the university, a public entity, had knowledge of the dangerous condition of the railing.
Students say Capistrano Hall is fairly outdated.
“This whole building needs a whole update,” said Jason Cruz, a music education major.
Brianne Gonzalez, a jazz studies major, said the overall comfort level of the building could be improved with just “a little attention.”
“It’s pretty old,” Gonzalez said. “There’s nothing necessarily wrong with it, but I do feel like there’s a lot that can be done in certain departments regarding funding.”
The case management conference for the case will be held May 14 of next year. All parties, as well as their lawyers and a judge, will meet to discuss how to move forward.
Additional reporting by Chris Wong.
Yuki • Dec 6, 2019 at 10:38 pm
Honestly…this should not be the school’s fault. It is a college campus that many Elementary-Highschool students attend. There has been zero issues with that railing until this incident…and to be fair the railings are at a regulatory height for adults. It’s safe for adults in my opinion…why would the school fix the campus to make it even more kid proof?
Klee • Dec 6, 2019 at 1:40 pm
As a mom myself, I get where the mom is coming from.. however call it what you may but mom should have paid more attention to her daughter regardless of trying to focus on signing in. My condolences to the baby girl.
Rieve • Dec 6, 2019 at 3:18 am
Its true that some people are money grubbing but you can’t just wrie her off like that. Look into the case where the woman who was burned by her coffee. Wasnt her fault that the coffee was so hot that it caused 3rd degree burns.
Philip Di Filippo • Dec 5, 2019 at 9:00 pm
Yvonne,
Sorry your having a bad day! If not that was an entirely uncalled for harangue of a woman who was registering her older child when her four year old slipped away. Having been a parent of small children it happens and her daughter’s injuries are no reason for you to go off as harshly as you have! If you are a student grow up!
Yvonne • Dec 5, 2019 at 5:44 pm
This is ridiculous maybe she should have been paying more attention to her children. Some people are money hungry sue happy ignorant waste of air.